Zimbabwe – should you be investing?
Zimbabwe’s political landscape has seemingly changed for the better after the resignation of President Robert Mugabe in November 2017. The interim president, Emmerson Mnangwaga, has come across as a more investor friendly leader than his predecessor. For one, the indigenisation policy of 51% local ownership for companies has been scrapped for all sectors except for diamond and platinum mining. Further to this, what it means to be ‘Zimbabwean’ has changed from being an indigenous Zimbabwean to being a citizen of Zimbabwe. The Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) has also created the Zimbabwe Portfolio Investment Fund which is aimed at facilitating repatriation of the sale proceeds and dividends of securities-related transactions to encourage new investors into the stock market.
However, the country is still plagued with currency shortages which is severely hindering the economy and the operational capability of companies – especially those who rely on imported inputs for their products. Many may argue that a better political environment will encourage international investors to bring money into the country in the form of foreign direct investment (FDI) or support from development finance institutions (DFIs). However, if investors can’t get their money out of the country, this is very unlikely in our opinion. Even the Zimbabwe Portfolio Investment Fund has not been adequately funded to clear the current backlog of investors waiting to exit the country.
We have in the recent past witnessed foreign currency shortages in Nigeria and Egypt, which chronically stalled these economies too. However, because these two countries had their own currencies, they could devalue to a point that attracted foreign investment and this provided the necessary foreign currency. Unfortunately, this is not an option for Zimbabwe as it does not have its own currency.
With all of this in mind, it’s interesting to note that the Zimbabwean stock market was the best performing stock market in Africa in 2017. However, this performance was largely driven by investors looking to hedge against currency shortages and devaluation fears (through the possible introduction of a new currency) by hiding in ‘real’ assets. When the perceived risk in the economy reduced after the resignation of Robert Mugabe, the stock market actually fell over 50% as indicated in Chart 1 below. The falling stock market was due to a more positive outlook on the economy by investors, which is counterintuitive.
However, this can be explained by the Old Mutual Implied rate which decreased considerable at this time. This is a comparison of the price of Old Mutual shares in London or Johannesburg and Harare and is used as a proxy as to what a “Zimbabwean” dollar is worth against the US dollar. This rate is currently around 40% as indicated in Chart 2 below, which is similar to the premium that you would get using physical US dollars in Zimbabwe, as opposed to paying with electronic dollars through the banking system.