The misuse of section 14 debarment proceedings: A growing regulatory concern
16 Nov, 2026

 

Charl Williams, Director; Parusha Chetty, Associate; & Tareq Allie, Candidate Attorney; Corporate & Commercial Law at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr

 

While the purpose underlying debarment procedures is sound, in practice a recurring point of contention is the use of the mechanism by FSPs for ulterior commercial or employment motives. Recent decisions by the Financial Services Tribunal (Tribunal) have reaffirmed that debarment proceedings are a regulatory mechanism aimed at protecting the public and not a tool for enforcing contractual rights or restraints, resolving labour or commercial disputes or workplace grievances.

 

What is debarment and how is it triggered?

 

The FSCA has described debarment as circumstances where a representative or any person is debarred on an industry-wide basis from rendering financial services to the investing public. A representative under the Financial Advisory and Intermediary Services Act 37 of 2002 (FAIS Act) is any person who renders financial services to a client for or on behalf of an FSP, in terms of conditions of employment or any other mandate. Depending on the process implemented, the regulatory framework governing debarment comprises the FAIS Act and/or the Financial Sector Regulation Act 9 of 2017 (FSR Act).

 

A debarment can be initiated by two distinct actors and through two processes:

  • in terms of section 14 of the FAIS Act which governs debarment by FSPs of its representatives (FSP initiated debarment); and
  • in terms of section 153 of the FSR Act, which governs debarment by the FSCA of a natural person.

 

Material substantive and procedural requirements applicable to FSP initiated debarment

 

An FSP initiated debarment is subject to several substantive and procedural requirements, which, prior to its implementation, must be lawful, reasonable and procedurally fair.

 

Substantive requirements or grounds for debarment

 

The individual must no longer meet the fit and proper requirements as contemplated in section 13(2)(a) or must have materially contravened or failed to comply with any provision of the FAIS Act. Notably, the reasons for debarment must have occurred and become known to the FSP while the individual was a representative of the FSP.

 

The fit and proper requirements are provided for in the Determination of Fit and Proper Requirements for Financial Services Providers, 2017, Board Notice 194 of 2017, published in the Government Gazette 41321 on 15 December 2017 (BN 194). In terms of section 4 of BN 194 these include: personal character qualities of honesty and integrity; good standing; competence; continuous professional development; operational ability; and financial soundness.

 

With particular focus on sections 8 and 9 of BN 194 this determination or test requires an assessment of whether the individual possesses the personal character qualifiers of honesty, integrity and good standing on the basis of objective facts that may demonstrate a lack of those qualities. Importantly, section 9(3) read with section 9(1) of BN 194 requires one to consider the conduct pertaining to the individual’s honesty, integrity and good standing in light of its seriousness, relevance and the lapse of time since its occurrence.

 

Procedural requirements

 

Prior to debarring a person, the FSP seeking to institute debarment proceedings against a representative must, inter alia:

  • give adequate written notice, stipulating its intention to debar, the grounds and reasons for the debarment, and any terms attached to the debarment;
  • provide the individual with a copy of the FSP’s written policy and procedure governing the debarment process; and
  • allow the individual a reasonable opportunity to make submissions in response; and
  • in cases where the person is no longer a representative of the FSP, commence the debarment no longer than six months from the date that the person ceased to be a representative of the FSP.

 

The FSP must consider any response provided by the individual, make a final decision and thereafter immediately notify the individual in writing of its decision, the individual’s rights and any formal requirements for reconsideration proceedings before the Tribunal.

 

The FSP must also withdraw any authority for the individual to act on its behalf, remove the individual’s name from the register of representatives, and ensure that the debarment does not prejudice the interests of clients. Additionally, the FSP must notify the FSCA within five days of the debarment and provide the grounds and reasons for the debarment within 15 days of the debarment.

 

Recent Tribunal decisions

 

In the 2024 Tribunal decision of Lefakane v ASI Financial Services (Pty) Limited (FSP32/2024) [2024] ZAFST 34 (19 July 2024) the applicant was a former employee of the FSP (respondent) and resigned shortly after receiving a retention bonus. Following her resignation, the FSP demanded repayment of the bonus, threatening legal proceedings. Several weeks later, the FSP initiated debarment proceedings in terms of section 14 of the FAIS Act, alleging that the applicant acted dishonestly and lacked the honesty and integrity required under the fit-and-proper requirements. The FSP made its decision to debar the applicant six months after the alleged misconduct.

 

The Tribunal noted the centrality of the dispute regarding the repayment of the retention bonus throughout the debarment process and as a result, questioned whether the debarment proceedings had been initiated for a legitimate regulatory purpose. The Tribunal held that the respondent’s actions raised concerns regarding the use of the debarment process for purposes beyond safeguarding the integrity of the financial sector, stating that:

 

“[T]he debarment seems to be used as a tactic to exert pressure in resolving a contractual dispute rather than a genuine reflection of the applicant’s fitness to act as a financial services representative.”

 

The Tribunal further pointed out that in line with the mandated procedure under the FAIS Act, a debarment should occur promptly after discovering that the representative no longer satisfies the fit and proper requirements, whereas in the present matter:

 

“[T]he respondent’s decision to debar the applicant came six months after the alleged misconduct. This extended delay raises questions about the respondent’s true motivations for debarment, potentially suggesting its use as leverage in resolving the employment dispute rather than a genuine concern about adherence to the FAIS Act.”

 

Ultimately, the Tribunal found that the debarment order was not justified under the FAIS Act, concluding that the debarment process had effectively been used to pursue a contractual dispute relating to the repayment of a retention bonus. It reaffirmed that section 14 debarment exists to protect the public from representatives who no longer meet the fit-and-proper requirements and should not be employed as leverage in contractual or employment-related disputes.

 

In the 2026 Tribunal decision of Laubscher v NWK 4 Sure Brokers (Pty) Limited (FSP26/2026) (8 July 2026) the applicant, a former key individual and representative of the FSP (respondent), informed the respondent that she would reach retirement age in a matter of months and indicated her willingness to continue rendering services on a fixed-term basis. A few weeks later the applicant gave written notice of her retirement, indicating her intention to continue working as a representative under another FSP.

The applicant’s employment contract with the FSP included a three-year restraint of trade and non-solicitation undertakings for the same period. The respondent viewed this as a competitive move that potentially breached restraint and non-solicitation obligations.

 

Following the applicant’s departure, she was debarred by the respondent, resulting in the applicant challenging the debarment on the basis that the grounds relied upon by the FSP were based on contractual, operational and commercial disputes arising from her retirement rather than genuine fit-and-proper concerns.

 

In setting out the legal framework the Tribunal:

  • drew a clear distinction between genuine fit-and-proper concerns on the one hand and contractual, employment-related and commercial disputes on the other;
  • clarified that debarment proceedings constitute a regulatory mechanism and “[t]he enquiry is therefore directed at serious regulatory misconduct, not ordinary contractual breaches or employer dissatisfaction”; and
  • emphasised that the purpose of the aforesaid regulatory mechanism is to protect the public (and not to assist FSPs in enforcing contractual rights or resolving employment, restraint or commercial disputes against representatives) and reiterated the jurisprudence developed within prior Tribunal decisions, in stating that:

 

“Labour disputes alone do not constitute grounds for debarment, nor does an adverse disciplinary finding automatically justify it … Consistently with the FSCA’s debarment guidance, a FSP may terminate a representative’s appointment without debarring where no statutory ground for debarment exists. The debarment power may not be exercised for ulterior purpose.”

 

The Tribunal held that alleged breach of the restraint of trade and the applicant’s intention to compete are contractual matters, further providing:

 

“[W]hile contractual obligations do not immunise genuinely regulatory misconduct, neither does the existence of a restraint transform every competitive departure into a regulatory breach.”

 

Importantly, the Tribunal reaffirmed that “[a]s Masebe [Masebe v Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd (FSP49/22) [2023] ZAFST] and the FSCA’s guidance make clear, the debarment power may not be used to enforce contractual restraints or resolve commercial disputes”.

 

The Tribunal held that the debarment was prompted primarily by the consequences of the applicant’s retirement and subsequent competition with the respondent rather than any genuine concern for public protection. While such conduct might potentially give rise to contractual, restraint-of-trade or employment remedies, it did not establish that the applicant lacked the fit-and-proper requirements or had materially contravened the FAIS Act. The debarment was accordingly set aside.

 

Analysis and key takeaways

 

These recent Tribunal decisions reaffirm that debarment is a regulatory mechanism aimed at protecting the public and preserving the integrity of the financial sector. It is not a tool for enforcing contractual rights, resolving employment disputes, preventing competition, or exerting pressure in commercial disagreements. The Tribunal has also clearly highlighted the misuse of debarment proceedings in achieving private outcomes.

 

The critical question in any FSP initiated debarment should not be whether the representative acted contrary to the employer’s interests, breached a restraint agreement, resigned unexpectedly, joined a competitor or became involved in a workplace dispute. The decisive enquiry remains whether the representative no longer satisfies the fit-and-proper requirements, as prescribed in BN 194, or has materially contravened financial sector legislation.

 

Importantly, BN 194 does not permit an FSP to debar a representative merely because a contractual, employment or commercial dispute has arisen. The fit and proper framework is directed at regulatory considerations pertaining to honesty, integrity and good standing rather than towards the protection of an FSP’s private commercial interests. As demonstrated by section 9(1) and (3) of BN 194, the nature of the enquiry is regulatory and character based. In contrast, disputes concerning restraint-of-trade obligations, resignations, retention-bonus repayments, commission disputes, client ownership disputes or other employment-related grievances do not demonstrate a lack of fitness and proprietary as contemplated in BN 194.

 

What has not been addressed by the Tribunal and what should be a topic of discussion is the power that is placed on or bestowed to FSPs to institute debarment procedures when they deem fit. Their discretion is significant and affords them the powers of financial sector authorities – which in turn opens the floodgates to misuse. FSPs, usually corporate entities that can afford legal fees, are often able to prolong proceedings against representatives without justifiable grounds for doing so. Concerningly, there are no penalties imposed upon FSPs for misuse of debarment proceedings and cost orders are only granted in exceptional circumstances, resulting in the representative bearing the burden even when approaching the Tribunal – creating a breeding ground for abuse.

 

FSPs should therefore exercise caution when considering debarment in circumstances involving resignations, post-employment competition, bonus repayment disputes or restraint-related disagreements. While those disputes may justify contractual or labour remedies, they do not automatically establish a basis for regulatory intervention under the FAIS Act.

 

The current legislative framework reveals a structural vulnerability in that section 14 of the FAIS Act places quasi-regulatory power in the hands of private commercial actors, namely FSPs who may have direct financial incentives to misuse such quasi-regulatory power. Furthermore, unlike the strict oversight requirements imposed upon the FSCA in terms of section 153, FSPs initiating debarment proceedings under the FAIS Act are not subjected to the risk of receiving statutory penalties for initiating debarment proceedings on a mala fide basis. In this regard, the worst regulatory outcome for the FSP is that the debarment is set aside and there is an outside chance of an adverse cost order if the representative can overcome the onerous burden of proof. A representative seeking recourse to cost orders in Tribunal proceedings require “exceptional circumstances” in terms of the FSR Act. This creates a moral hazard: the FSP has little to lose by launching a spurious debarment while the representative bears the full burden of defending against it.

 

ENDS

Author

@Charl Williams, Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr
+ posts
@Parusha Chetty, Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr
@Tareq Allie, Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr
Share on Your Socials

Share

Subscribe to the EBnet Daily Newsletter and WhatsApp Community for the latest retirement funding, financial planning, and investment news, along with market updates and special announcements.

Subscribe to

Thank You. You have been subscribed. Please check your emails for a confirmation mail.