Already diversified? Here’s where an actively managed ETF could add value
19 Nov, 2026

 

Eric Moyo, Sales Research Analyst at Satrix

 

Say you’ve done the groundwork. You’ve spread your money across local and global shares, bonds, property and a bit of cash. You’ve stuck to the basics, and you feel fairly sorted. Then one evening, scrolling through your investment app, you come across something called an actively managed ETF (AMETF).

 

An AMETF is an exchange traded fund that you buy and sell on the JSE, just like any other ETF. The difference is that the portfolio is actively managed, with a portfolio manager making investment decisions on the fund, rather than simply replicating an index. The portfolio manager chooses what to hold, what to sell and adjusts the portfolio as market valuation changes. You get a manager’s expertise with the ease of access of an ETF.

 

The good news is that you don’t have to start over. Your diversified portfolio may already be doing exactly what it was built to do, and an AMETF can work alongside it rather than replace it. The real question is where could a manager’s active decisions add something different or complementary in your portfolio?

 

Think of it like cooking

 

I like to explain it using a kitchen analogy. Following a recipe can give you a perfectly good meal. However, you could also let a chef make some of the decisions along the way. The chef can adjust things based on experience, but that doesn’t mean their meal will be better.

 

Traditional index-tracking ETFs work like the recipe. They aim to mirror an index, so you always know what you’re following. An AMETF brings in the chef. Instead of sticking to an index, some of these funds lean heavily on the manager’s judgement, and others follow a more rules-based process, so it’s worth checking how yours works. Either way, you can still buy and sell it on the JSE like any other ETF.

 

Meet Thandiwe

 

We’ll use Thandiwe, a 38-year-old teacher from Pretoria, to show how AMETFs and ETFs can complement each other. She’s been investing for a few years, and she’s done what most good advice tells you to do: spread her money around.

 

A quarter of her portfolio (25%) is in South African shares. Another 25% is in global shares, so she isn’t relying only on how things go at home. She invests 20% in a multi-asset fund, 15% in fixed income, 10% in property and the last 5% in cash for a rainy day.

 

On paper, Thandiwe has her bases covered. So, when she comes across an AMETF, she doesn’t need to find a new spot for it as if it were another asset class. It sits inside one she already owns.

 

Take her 15% in fixed income. Thandiwe could leave 10% in an index-tracking ETF and move 5% into a fixed income AMETF. She’d still have 15% invested in fixed income. What changes is how some of her money is managed.

 

The tracker still follows its index. With an AMETF, the manager can make investment decisions within the fund’s rules as market conditions change. For example, the manager may have a view on where interest rates are heading and adjust the portfolio accordingly. They can also decide which bonds to hold and how much risk to take.

 

That’s the kind of work Thandiwe doesn’t have the time or know-how to do herself. Between marking papers and fetching the kids, who does?

 

It’s also why we launched the Satrix Income AMETF earlier this year, our first actively managed ETF. In parts of the income market, there’s no single index that neatly captures the opportunity. So, the manager positions the fund based on their view of the interest rate cycle, while investors still get the transparency and ease of an ETF.

 

No guarantees, so go in with your eyes open

 

Bringing in a manager doesn’t guarantee better results. A manager won’t always get their decisions right or deliver better returns.

 

So, before Thandiwe makes a move, she should weigh up what she’s getting against what she’s giving up. That means looking at the fees, the risk and how much complexity it adds to her portfolio. Then she can ask herself whether the extra flexibility is worth it.

 

Start with the task, not the percentage

 

People often ask me how much they should hand over to an active manager. There isn’t a single way to split between active and index tracking that works for everyone.

 

Rather than starting with a percentage, think about where you see value in active management and what you want the manager to do.

 

Is your goal income, growth or simply a different approach? Once you know what you want the money to do, you can decide whether an AMETF is the right tool. How much you put in will depend on your goals and how much risk you’re comfortable with.

 

Not either-or, but both

 

If there’s one thing I’d like you to take away, it’s that you don’t have to choose between active and index tracking. They can coexist in the same portfolio.

 

Thandiwe keeps her recipe and lets the chef handle a dish or two, while the rest of the meal stays exactly as she planned it.

 

ENDS

Author

@Eric Moyo, Satrix
+ posts
Share on Your Socials

Share

Subscribe to the EBnet Daily Newsletter and WhatsApp Community for the latest retirement funding, financial planning, and investment news, along with market updates and special announcements.

Subscribe to

Thank You. You have been subscribed. Please check your emails for a confirmation mail.