Estate planning tools can have unexpected tax consequences
16 Nov, 2026

 

Jainal Narsai, fiduciary specialist at Alexforbes

 

Estate planning often focuses on a straightforward question: who should receive your assets when you die? The way those assets are transferred can be just as important.

 

Tools such as usufructs, habitatios and fideicommissa can help provide for loved ones while determining how assets pass to future beneficiaries. They can be particularly useful when someone wants one beneficiary to enjoy an asset while preserving it for another beneficiary later.

 

These arrangements can, however, have tax consequences that are easily overlooked. Estate duty, capital gains tax (CGT) and income tax may all need to be considered before deciding whether a particular structure is appropriate.

 

How these estate planning tools work

 

Usufructs, habitatios and fideicommissa separate, in different ways, the right to benefit from an asset from its ownership. A usufruct gives a person the right to use and enjoy an asset and receive the income it generates while ownership rests with another person. The person who holds this right is known as the usufructuary, while the underlying owner holds the bare dominium. A habitatio is narrower and gives a person the right to live in a property. A fideicommissum allows an asset to pass from one beneficiary to another at a later stage, usually subject to conditions set out in a will.

 

These arrangements can help meet different family needs. An estate plan might, for example, seek to provide for one beneficiary while ensuring that an asset eventually passes to another beneficiary or future generation. The potential tax consequences should form part of that decision rather than being considered only after the structure has been established.

 

Estate duty can affect the outcome

 

Estate duty is an important consideration. When assets are left to a surviving spouse, an estate may qualify for the deduction under section 4(q) of the Estate Duty Act. This can reduce the estate duty payable on qualifying property.

 

The position can differ when a usufruct, habitatio or fideicommissum benefits someone other than the surviving spouse, such as a child or another family member. The available deduction and resulting estate duty therefore need to be considered when the arrangement is established.

 

Usufructs and habitatios also require the value of the right granted to the beneficiary to be determined. Prescribed actuarial calculations are used and take factors such as the beneficiary’s age into account when establishing the value of the benefit.

 

Generally, a right that is expected to be enjoyed for longer will have a higher value. A younger beneficiary may therefore result in a higher value being attributed to the right because it is expected to continue for a longer period. That valuation can affect the estate duty calculation and, consequently, what is ultimately available to beneficiaries. This illustrates why the legal intention behind an estate plan cannot be separated from its tax treatment. An arrangement designed to provide for a family member may have a different financial outcome once the relevant tax consequences are taken into account.

 

CGT adds another consideration

 

CGT can also arise when someone dies. For tax purposes, a deceased person’s assets are generally treated as though they were disposed of at market value on the date of death. This deemed disposal can result in a capital gain that may be subject to tax.

 

Usufructs and habitatios can add complexity because rights in the asset are divided between the person entitled to use or occupy it and the person who holds the underlying ownership. The estate plan therefore needs to account for the tax treatment of those different interests instead of considering only the asset as a whole.

 

A fideicommissum can introduce further complexity because the asset is intended to pass from one beneficiary to another in future. As rights to the asset change, further tax consequences may arise. People considering these arrangements should therefore look beyond what happens immediately after death. The way rights are structured and how they change over time can be relevant to the tax outcome.

 

Income tax does not necessarily end with the estate

 

The tax implications can continue after the estate has been administered, particularly when an asset produces income. Under a usufruct, the beneficiary entitled to enjoy the asset is generally also entitled to the income it produces.

 

If a property subject to a usufruct is rented out, for example, the rental income is generally taxable in the hands of the usufructuary rather than the bare dominium holder. Once the usufruct ends and full ownership passes to the bare dominium holder, the tax treatment of income generated by the asset will change accordingly.

 

Knowing who is entitled to the income and who is responsible for the associated tax at each stage can help prevent misunderstandings and disputes between beneficiaries. It can also help ensure that the arrangement is administered in line with its intended purpose.

 

Consider the full tax picture

 

Usufructs, habitatios and fideicommissa can serve valuable estate planning purposes, particularly when different beneficiaries have rights to the same asset at different times. Their usefulness should not obscure their potential tax consequences. The effect of estate duty, CGT and income tax will depend on the assets concerned, the rights created, the beneficiaries involved and the structure of the estate plan. An arrangement that appears straightforward from a succession perspective may have financial implications that affect both the estate and the people it is intended to benefit.

 

Professional fiduciary, legal and tax advice should therefore be obtained before putting these arrangements in place. Effective estate planning requires a clear understanding of who will receive an asset, who will have the right to use it or benefit from its income and when those rights will end. Considering the tax consequences at the same time can reduce the risk of an estate plan producing an unintended outcome.

 

ENDS

Author

@Jainal Narsai, Alexforbes
+ posts
Share on Your Socials

Share

Subscribe to the EBnet Daily Newsletter and WhatsApp Community for the latest retirement funding, financial planning, and investment news, along with market updates and special announcements.

Subscribe to

Thank You. You have been subscribed. Please check your emails for a confirmation mail.