SA asset managers are taking very different bets on the JSE. That may be a good thing.
16 Nov, 2026

 

Mubeen Abdulla, Senior Investment Consultant, Simeka Consultants and Actuaries (Pty) Ltd

 

Retirement fund trustees choosing investment managers on behalf of their members face a difficult question: what exactly should they be choosing for? Past performance? Where a manager is investing today? Or whether that manager favours the part of the JSE – large, mid or small caps – that is currently outperforming?

 

The trouble is that today’s winner may not be tomorrow’s. Market-cap leadership changes, and trying to predict which part of the market will lead next is never really possible.

 

The answer, as is so often the case in investing, lies in diversification. But not simply in appointing more managers. It means deliberately choosing managers with different investment philosophies and sources of conviction, so that the portfolio is not dependent on one manager, one style or one part of the market getting the call right.

 

We looked closely at 18 prominent South African asset managers and found how differently managers are making those calls. Around 55% of those surveyed are overweight large caps relative to the FTSE/JSE Capped All Share Index, while 60% are overweight small caps. Interestingly, those differences are not neatly explained by whether the manager is a large established house or a smaller boutique.

 

The JSE keeps changing its mind

 

Recent history helps explain why this matters. Large, mid- and small-cap shares have each moved through periods of leadership as market conditions have changed. Small caps benefited strongly from the post-Covid growth rebound in 2021 and again from improving domestic sentiment around the GNU, economic reform and the start of the interest-rate cutting cycle in 2024.

 

In 2025, the picture changed as the precious-metals rally favoured parts of the large-cap market. In 2026, as the rally cooled, smaller companies began catching up again.

 

Chart 1: SA Equity Market Cap Performance

Source: IRESS

 

The lesson is not which segment performed best. It is how difficult it is to predict which will lead next.

 

Large caps are fewer in number but dominate liquidity and trading activity on the JSE. Small caps are greater in number but tend to have lower liquidity and less research coverage, creating a different mix of opportunity and risk. Mid-caps sit somewhere between the two.

 

What managers are doing

 

Our research looked at the small-, mid- and large-cap exposures of 18 prominent asset managers within their flagship SA equity funds, as at 31 July 2026.

 

Chart 2: Asset manager market cap exposures

Source: Asset managers

 

Where applicable, allocations have been rescaled to 100% to account for small cash holdings within surveyed SA equity portfolios.

 

Large caps remain the foundation of most portfolios, but managers disagree considerably about how much exposure they want. Around 55% are overweight large caps, favouring greater liquidity and lower trading costs, while the remainder are underweight.

 

Around 60% are overweight small caps, where lower research coverage can create opportunities to identify mispricing, although lower liquidity makes meaningful positions harder to establish or exit. Mid-cap positioning varies considerably too.

 

Managers do not all classify small, mid- and large-cap companies in exactly the same way, so the findings are best viewed as an indication of relative positioning rather than a perfectly like-for-like comparison.

 

But the spread itself tells us something important: there is no single industry view on where the opportunity lies.

 

Diversifying conviction, not just managers

 

This is where the research becomes useful for trustees. A value-oriented manager may see a very different opportunity from a growth or quality-focused manager. One may find attractive opportunities among under-researched smaller businesses, while another places greater emphasis on liquidity, scale or earnings resilience.

 

Neither necessarily has to be wrong

 

For trustees, the distinction highlights the role that different sources of investment conviction can play within a diversified portfolio, particularly where managers’ portfolios behave differently from one another.

 

There are broadly two approaches seen in practice. A core-satellite model combines lower-cost passive exposure with selected high-conviction active managers. Another is a blend of high-conviction active managers across the full equity allocation, which gives managers greater freedom to pursue opportunities across the market-cap spectrum, albeit at a higher cost.

 

The latter relies on genuine differentiation between the managers selected.

 

Simply appointing several active managers does not necessarily result in meaningful diversification if they own similar companies for similar reasons. The important distinction is the extent to which managers differ, and whether their investment philosophies provide the overall portfolio with genuinely different sources of return.

 

Tomorrow’s winner is unknowable

 

Nobody knows with certainty whether the JSE’s next sustained period of leadership will come from large, mid- or small caps. This uncertainty illustrates the potential value of portfolios that are not reliant on that call being right.

 

If market leadership continues to rotate, a combination of genuinely differentiated managers may provide exposure to opportunities across the market, while reducing reliance on any single investment style, market-cap segment or view of what happens next. The research therefore suggests that manager differentiation may be an important consideration for trustees when constructing diversified portfolios.

 

ENDS

Author

@Mubeen Abdulla, Simeka Consultants & Actuaries
+ posts
Share on Your Socials

Share

Subscribe to the EBnet Daily Newsletter and WhatsApp Community for the latest retirement funding, financial planning, and investment news, along with market updates and special announcements.

Subscribe to

Thank You. You have been subscribed. Please check your emails for a confirmation mail.