Lize de la Harpe, Senior Legal Advisor: Sanlam Life & Savings: Regulatory Unit
Introduction
Up until recently, Namibian retirement funds were regulated by the South African Pension Funds Act. This is no longer the case.
The new legal framework that regulates Namibia’s non-banking financial sector officially came into force on 1 May 2026. Let’s unpack the impact of this new law on a fund’s ability to deduct compensation due to an employer in respect damage caused to the employer by reason of theft, dishonesty, fraud or misconduct.
The South African Pension Funds Act, 1956
The primary purpose of a retirement fund is to provide retirement benefits and death benefits. It is for this reason that pension benefits are protected against creditors. Section 37A of the Pension Funds Act specifically states that a benefit provided for in the rules of a registered pension fund or a right to such benefit, shall not (save for certain exceptions) be capable of being reduced or be liable to be attached or subjected to any form of execution under a judgment or order of court.
Section 37D in turn sets out certain permissible deductions, including the deduction of compensation due to an employer in respect damages caused by the member to the employer by reason of theft, dishonesty, fraud or misconduct in respect of which the member has admitted liability in writing, or judgment has been obtained in court.
In cases where the employee has not admitted liability and the employer is forced to approach the courts to establish such employee’s liability, usually the employee will have already exited the fund due to being dismissed by their employer or resigning. Upon dismissal or resignation, the member typically (subject to Two Pot restrictions) becomes entitled to a withdrawal benefit. If the member was paid his or her withdrawal benefit before the employer was able to obtain a judgment against them, such court order may be rendered futile.
Our courts have confirmed that the wording of section 37D(1)(b) of the Pension Funds Act implies the right of the fund to withhold a benefit payable to the former employee pending a court order or admission of guilt, when requested to do so by the employer.
The Financial Institutions and Markets Act, 2021
The Financial Institutions and Markets Act, 2021 (FIMA) which came into operation on 1 May 2026 has repealed the South African Pension Funds Act. FIMA is now the central law governing financial institutions in Namibia, including retirement funds.
Chapter 5 of FIMA deals with retirement funds and contains provisions that are very similar to what is contained in South Africa’s Pension Fundds Act, including provisions relating to the protection of pensions benefits against creditors and also making provision for certain permissible deductions. What is notably absent, however, is a deduction in respect of compensation due to an employer as a result of damages caused by an employee.
Put simply: FIMA contains no provision similar to section 37D(1)(b) of the South African Pension Funds Act which would enable a fund to make a deduction from a member’s benefit for damages caused to an employer.
Central-North Electricity Distribution Company (Pty) Ltd v Fungo [2026] NAHCMD 598 (5 October 2026)
The applicant (the employer) brought an application to the High Court of Namibia for an urgent interdict against the Retirement Fund for Local Authorities and Utility Services in Namibia (the Fund) barring it from releasing the second respondent’s (former employee) pension benefit which the Fund had been withholding pursuant to a request from the application under section 37D of the Pension Funds Act.
In essence, the court had to determine if an employer can still rely on a pension fund’s withholding of benefits under section 37D now that FIMA has repealed the Pension Funds Act.
The applicant alleged that its former analyst, Mr Fungo, procured 303 irregular procurement transactions totalling NAD 12,369,663.56 between January 2021 and December 2022. He resigned on 9 January 2023, before disciplinary proceedings began. At the applicant’s request, the Fund withheld his benefits of approximately NAD 592,614 under section 37D of the Pension Funds Act pending the determination of its civil claim for damages.
On 31 July 2026 the Fund’s legal representatives prepared an internal memo advising the Fund that, in light of the commencement of FIMA, it had no lawful reason to continue to withhold the second respondent’s benefit. Its position was that paragraph 2(5) of Schedule 3 to FIMA preserves a right accrued under a repealed law only where FIMA contains a comparable provision, and that section 37D has none. It characterised the applicant’s position as a contingent expectation rather than an accrued right.
The applicant relied on accrued rights under the repealed Pension Funds Act which rights, it argued, were preserved under the transitional provisions of FIMA. It specifically invoked section 467 of FIMA, read with Schedule 3, and section 11 of the Interpretation of Laws Proclamation 37 of 1920 in support of its contention that the accrued rights under section 37D of the Pension Funds Act survived the repeal of the Pension Funds Act. The applicant relied on Highveld Steel and Vanadium Corportaiton Ltd v Oosthuixen and Municipality of Swakopmund v Kandenge in support of its position. Both cited authorities, however, were decided under the Pension Funds Act before FIMA came into effect.
Turning to the law, the court confirmed that in order to succeed with the application, the applicant must show that it had a prima facie right to the pension benefit – which it failed to do. The second respondent did not admit liability and no judgment has been obtained against him. As such, the pension benefits belong to the second respondent, not the applicant. Based on the fact that the requirements for an urgent interdict had not been met, the application was accordingly dismissed.
Conclusion
The key take away from this judgment can be summarised as follows: FIMA does not contain a similar provision to section 37D of the Pension Funds Act which enables a fund to withhold a pension benefit and eventually make a deduction in respect of compensation due to an employer by reason of theft, fraud, misconduct or dishonesty. This can have a significant impact on employers who have no other recourse against a former employee. It remains to be seen if the judgment will withstand scrutiny of a higher court.
ENDS






